Passer à la navigation principale Passer à la recherche Passer au contenu principal

Modelling Density, Relative Abundance and Threats in a Highly Mobile Marine Vertebrate
: Implications for Spatio-temporal Management of Minke Whales in Western Scotland

  • Tim Awbery

Student thesis: Doctor of Philosophy (awarded by UHI)

Résumé

Mobile megafauna pose a complex management challenge. While 1 cetaceans are
well documented to make large-scale movements between breeding and feeding
grounds, the modelling of their distribution, as well as their management is often
treated as static. In the north-east Atlantic, the wider migratory movements of
minke whales remain poorly understood, despite regular sightings on feeding
grounds in western Scottish waters. Fine-scale spatio-temporal distribution
models have been limited to small areas or multi-year averages, and despite the
establishment of the Sea of the Hebrides Marine Protected Area (MPA) in 2020,
which lists minke whales as a priority feature, an associated management plan
remains limited.
Entanglement in pot-fishing rope is considered the greatest threat to minke
whales in Scottish waters, causing an estimated 30 deaths annually. Fatal vessel
strikes also occur, with confirmed records likely an underestimate of true mortality. Vessel disturbance has further been shown to reduce foraging and limit
communication space. This thesis therefore aimed to characterise the spatio16
temporal distribution of minke whales in Scottish and adjacent waters and
identify where whales and anthropogenic activities overlap, to inform
management and conservation within the MPA and across wider western
Scottish waters.
Non-systematic vessel survey data collected by the Hebridean Whale and
Dolphin Trust (2004–2023) were used to build Density Surface Models, generating
predictions of distribution and relative abundance from 22 March to November in
2022 and 2023. Likelihood of exposure to pot-fishing was estimated by
overlapping two independent proxies of fishing effort. Similarly, likelihood of
vessel exposure was estimated from density data across vessel classes.
Acoustic analysis across 19 recording stations (2020–2021) supplemented the
visual data, with a dynamic model of minke whale vocalisation presence
compared against the visual predictions.
Visual survey predictions indicated minke whales arrive in the south-west of the
study area in March, move northward through summer, and are predominantly in
the north by October. Stanton Banks remained important year-round, though
with greater uncertainty given its position at the survey edge. Relative abundance
peaked at ~2,300 animals in July 2023 before declining through autumn. The
proportion of these minke whales within the MPA at any one time peaked at ~0.35
in September in 2023.
Pot fishing distribution was broadly stable across the year, though pot counts
increased over time. Total rope in western Scottish waters was estimated at
~12,000 km. Four priority areas of persistently high whale–fishery overlap were
identified, two within the MPA, with highest exposure in summer. Vessel exposure
was also highest in summer, with spatial and temporal variation across vessel
classes. The acoustic analysis extended spatial and seasonal coverage,
including December–February. Predictions broadly aligned with the visual
model, confirming the importance of Stanton Banks from Spring to Autumn.
Further, the acoustic model suggested a westward departure 44 in autumn and
near-absence of vocalising whales in winter.
The modelling frameworks developed in this thesis are applied to this particular
case study but are transferable to any species where similar data exists.
Limitations of techniques are discussed and suggestions for research to further
enhance our spatio-temporal understanding of mobile marine megafauna are
made. The results of this thesis substantially improve current understanding of
the distribution, relative abundance and threats of minke whales in western
Scottish waters. These findings should be used to inform monitoring plans and
policy development for both the Sea of the Hebrides MPA and at a national level.
la date de réponse10 juin 2026
langue originaleEnglish
L'institution diplômante
  • University of the Highlands and Islands
SuperviseurDenise Risch (Supervisor) & Ben Wilson (Supervisor)

Contient cette citation

'