TY - JOUR
T1 - Adaptive value of participatory biodiversity monitoring in community forestry
AU - Lawrence, Anna
AU - Paudel, Krishna
AU - Barnes, Richard
AU - Malla, Yam
N1 - Article produced while at University of Oxford; full text available from https://ora.ox.ac.uk/
PY - 2006/12/1
Y1 - 2006/12/1
N2 - In the context of action research in community forests, stakeholders' values for biodiversity can be elicited, communicated and understood with the help of a multidimensional conceptual framework. This incorporates levels of diversity (genes, species, habitats and processes), types of values (direct use, indirect use, option and existence) and stakeholders. This paper explores the effect of using this framework on forest monitoring, learning and communication, and wider implications for conservation, in Baglung District (Nepal). Monitoring was initially an unfamiliar concept to villagers, but the process clarified its purpose, whilst helping to elicit and exchange values and knowledge amongst stakeholders. This precipitated proposals for silvicultural experimentation and social inquiry into the diversity of users' needs. The framework allowed the translation of local value statements into categories recognized by other actors. It aided external stakeholders in understanding the factors contributing to values held by community forest users. Villagers' appreciation of 'quality' forest did not necessarily equate to the most 'biodiverse' forest, but rather the greenest and densest and that stocked with useful species. Elite domination, tenure and access to markets affected values assigned and behaviour in forest management. Elicitation of these values provoked questioning of forest management decisions and benefit sharing among community forest users. This, in turn, stimulated more democratic forest management and more inclusive, wide-ranging biodiversity values. Participatory monitoring is more conceptually challenging than is usually recognized, and the links between equity and conservation merit further attention in different cultural contexts.
AB - In the context of action research in community forests, stakeholders' values for biodiversity can be elicited, communicated and understood with the help of a multidimensional conceptual framework. This incorporates levels of diversity (genes, species, habitats and processes), types of values (direct use, indirect use, option and existence) and stakeholders. This paper explores the effect of using this framework on forest monitoring, learning and communication, and wider implications for conservation, in Baglung District (Nepal). Monitoring was initially an unfamiliar concept to villagers, but the process clarified its purpose, whilst helping to elicit and exchange values and knowledge amongst stakeholders. This precipitated proposals for silvicultural experimentation and social inquiry into the diversity of users' needs. The framework allowed the translation of local value statements into categories recognized by other actors. It aided external stakeholders in understanding the factors contributing to values held by community forest users. Villagers' appreciation of 'quality' forest did not necessarily equate to the most 'biodiverse' forest, but rather the greenest and densest and that stocked with useful species. Elite domination, tenure and access to markets affected values assigned and behaviour in forest management. Elicitation of these values provoked questioning of forest management decisions and benefit sharing among community forest users. This, in turn, stimulated more democratic forest management and more inclusive, wide-ranging biodiversity values. Participatory monitoring is more conceptually challenging than is usually recognized, and the links between equity and conservation merit further attention in different cultural contexts.
KW - Adaptive management
KW - Environmental democracy
KW - Equity
KW - Ethnobotany
KW - Forest management
KW - Indicators
KW - Nepal
KW - Tenure
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33846860587&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33846860587&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1017/S0376892906003432
DO - 10.1017/S0376892906003432
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:33846860587
SN - 0376-8929
VL - 33
SP - 325
EP - 334
JO - Environmental Conservation
JF - Environmental Conservation
IS - 4
ER -